Personal Bankruptcy and the Accumulation of Shadow Debt

From Bronson Argyle, Benjamin Iverson, Taylor Nadauld and Christopher Palmer

Compiling new liability-level data from the balance sheets of personal bankruptcy filers, we document that a sizable share of reported liabilities are “shadow debt,” debt not reported to credit bureaus that often arises from the non-payment of goods and services. We use this new data to evaluate how debtor cash flows affect when consumers file for bankruptcy and how much debt they have at bankruptcy. We find that filers respond to a quasi-exogenous $100 increase in monthly cash flows by delaying filing by an average of one month and by increasing unsecured indebtedness by $4,000 in the months preceding filing. A large share of the additional debt incurred by delaying filers is shadow debt, and our effects are concentrated among filers without employment, health, or marriage shocks.

Learn More about Lending Markets

Current Lending Markets projects from the Consumer Finance Initiative cover topics including mortgage refinancing, lending standards and shadow debt and bankruptcy. Find more Lending Markets research here.